Colts Continue to Grapple with Significant Uncertainty Following 2025 Offseason Changes

As the Indianapolis Colts dive into the core of their offseason preparations, a critical question lingers: who will secure the starting quarterback role? Despite bolstering the roster with new talent and depth, the team has yet to resolve the uncertainty surrounding its most pivotal position.

Anthony Richardson, drafted fourth overall, remains the frontrunner on paper. Yet, his recurring injuries and inconsistent performance have sparked doubts within the organization. To address this, the Colts signed Daniel Jones in free agency as a potential safeguard. While not viewed as a permanent solution, Jones’ experience and past playoff run provide head coach Shane Steichen with a reliable alternative should Richardson struggle early on.

Further complicating the quarterback situation is rookie Riley Leonard, who some analysts see as a potential dark horse for playing time this season. Initially pegged as a developmental prospect, Leonard’s skill set aligns seamlessly with Shane Steichen’s offensive scheme, which prioritizes RPOs and short-to-intermediate passing—areas where Leonard excels. His dual-threat ability and extensive college experience under coaches like David Cutcliffe and Mike Denbrock strengthen his case.

NFL analysts, including PFF, have praised Leonard as one of the better rookie quarterback fits in the league. If neither Anthony Richardson nor Daniel Jones emerges as the clear starter during training camp, there’s growing speculation that Leonard could be accelerated into a more significant role.

The Colts are projected to finish around .500, with FanDuel setting their win total at 7.5. In a competitive AFC South, effective quarterback play could determine whether the team makes a playoff push or faces another lackluster season. Daniel Jones, with his extensive experience, could have an edge in the training camp battle, potentially revitalized by a fresh start in Indianapolis.

With high stakes and little margin for error, the quarterback competition remains the Colts’ most critical and defining storyline heading into the 2025 season.